Home AMX User Forum AMXForums Archive Threads AMX Hardware

DELAY BOOT? HELP!

Greetings,
my new "business class" switches (Cisco SG200-08P) boot slower than my NI-3100s so the NI gives up trying for its static ip. then it just sits there.....

any clue how I can delay start-up?

Thanks,
John

Comments

  • viningvining Posts: 4,368
    I assume your NI's aren't static then and you have them bound by client id or mac in your switch which is also acting as the dhcp server for this vlan. You could actual make your NI's static and then they won't need to make the dhcp request in the first place. You can enter the reserved adresses in the excluded table or just leave it in the static table so the switch knows not to assign that address or just give the NI's an IP outside of the switch's vlan dhcp pool.

    If you want to keep the NI's dhcp but static bound in the switch for whatever reason you could then write code to telnet into the master to get it's ip address and if it's in the auto private range then try to ping the switch. When you can ping the switch then issue a reboot of the NI. When in come back test for a proper IP again.

    I also use SG300 switches but I keep it on another ethernet controlled outlet and never reboot all outlets at the same time, usually even if I do thet'd be sequenced.
  • jsnyderjsnyder Posts: 23
    Yup, it's set static.

    and a serial terminal "get ip" returns correct info. along with a msg about timeout on a try for the master in it's url list. over and over again.

    rebooting the master (via terminal) restores it.

    the switch is default config with no vlan specified.

    Thanks.
  • viningvining Posts: 4,368
    I thought you were having DHCP issues but it's M2M that isn't working. So this only happens when you cycle power that controls the switch and the master that holds the URL list? First thing would be to put on separate controllable outlets so you can cycle power on the NI but not the switch but then in case of power outages, etc you might want and code reads the log msg's like Dave Hawthorne's DevTerminal Logger so when you see that message you can ping the switch or just a wait and reboot(0) or however that command works. I haven't programmed in a while so I'm rusty.
  • jsnyderjsnyder Posts: 23
    DELAY BOOT?

    Alas, no joy...
    I tried setting a reboot in code so if TP1 goes offline it should reboot the master.
    sadly, since the master boots before the switch can hand out an ip TP1 never makes it "online" in the masters eyes
    so it never goes "offline".

    (bash cranium against wall here)
  • John NagyJohn Nagy Posts: 1,733
    A hammer approach...

    After master boot, attempt a code interaction with the slave. If you get through, continue.
    If you don't, wait 1 minute and reboot.
    (Put a telnet message up saying it looks like the M2M isn't ready, and maybe allow a manual abort (via telnet) of the reboot for test purposes.)

    Creeping featurisms:
    You can add a counter in non-volatile variable that is zeroed on slave communication being established, and increment it on each reboot. And stop the rebooting if the count goes to 5 or so... which would mean it isn't happening. Keep the master running and reset the counter to 0 for the eventual next session.

    You could increase the wait time for each reboot, based on the variable, such that you have time to recover if there is transient network trouble. Say, boot 4 waits 5 minutes instead of 1, and boot 5 waits 15. So 5 boots gives you 23 minutes to get the network happy.

    You could periodically verify M2M after that, if needed, say check once an hour or maybe once a day.

    And DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT. The above behavior would make any tech crazy if they didn't know it was happening or why.
  • ericmedleyericmedley Posts: 4,177
    Well, you can't embed the code in the event. You won't get an initial event upon startup.

    I'd just make a integer flag that gets set at the TP online event to one. Also put the flag back to zero in the offline event.

    Then on startup create a wait that will give the to enough time to connect f the switch is up and running. Then after the want check for the flag value. If the TP is still offline you can reboot the Netlinx master then.

    I will go on record as saying I'm not a fan of this method as it puts another device in the mx that may or may not be the cause of the problem.

    The way I'd approach this is to turn on SNMP on the network switch and just try to hit the switch for a response. If no response, reboot.
  • jsnyderjsnyder Posts: 23
    DELAY BOOT? HELP!

    Hi all,
    thanks for the attempts!

    John: since the master boots before the switch, TP1 never makes it "online" in the masters eyes
    so it never goes "offline". no slave to play with either :( .
    and like you pointed out: making it rely on an external item is bad.

    Eric: could you please give me a code example of a "wait on startup"? what I used is not working.

    Thanks!
  • ericmedleyericmedley Posts: 4,177
    I'm typing this from scratch on my iPad. So, no promises it compiles
    DEFINE_DEVICE
    
    dvTP =10001:01:0
    
    DEFINE_VARIABLE
     volatile integer TP_onlne_flag;
    
    
    Define_function startup_reboot_check(){
        If( TP_onlne_flag=0){
          reboot(0)
          }
      }// def_fun
    
    DEFINE_START
    WAIT 2400{
         startup_reboot_check()
       }// wait
    
    DEFNE_EVENT
    
    data_event[dvTP]{
        Online:{
          TP_onlne_flag=1
        }
        Offline:{
          TP_onlne_flag=0
        }
      }//d_e
    
    
    
    

    I am assuming the max time to reboot the switch is under 4 minutes (Wait 2400 ).

    So, what happens here is the flag variable will boot up zero until the panel comes online and then get set to 1. In the mean time at the 4 minute mark the program will check the value if the flag. If the network switch was up and working correctly AND the TP was connected to the master, the flag will be 1 and no reboot.

    But if 4 minutes goes by and the network switch still hasn't cone up yet the master will reboot and try again.

    Here again, I wouldn't do it this way myself. But to at least answer your question here is some code.
  • jsnyderjsnyder Posts: 23
    DELAY BOOT? HELP!

    We have a winner!!!

    Thanks Eric!

    I've never used a volatile integer before, awesome sauce!

    Back to soldering stuff, Have a swell week!

    Sincerely,
    John
Sign In or Register to comment.